Our Take
For most drivers in 2026, buying a used car is the financially superior choice. A 2023–2024 model, purchased for $18,450 and driven for 60 months, costs $24,100 total, including depreciation, insurance, and maintenance, versus $32,470 for a comparable 2026 model leased at $613/month. Leasing only wins for those under 12,000 miles annually, valuing new tech, or planning to switch vehicles every three years. The catch? Lease end fees, wear-and-tear charges, and higher insurance premiums for new vehicles often offset savings. A 2026 lease with a 24% residual value still leaves you with no equity.
Car ownership remains one of the largest financial decisions most Americans face. With new-car prices hitting $49,461 in April 2026 and financing rates still elevated, many are reevaluating whether to lease or buy. High insurance costs for newer models, rising inflation, and stagnant wage growth have made the math more complex. But the data shows a clear winner for long-term drivers: a used car.
This article is for people deciding between leasing a 2026 model or buying a 2023–2024 used vehicle. It’s based on 2026 pricing, current insurance trends, and real cost comparisons. The recommendation works for those who want to minimize long-term ownership costs and build equity. It falters for frequent upgraders, high-mileage drivers, or those tied to manufacturer incentives.
Key Takeaways
- The average monthly lease payment for a new car in 2025 was $613, according to Experian’s Q4 2025 data.
- Over 50% of EV drivers chose to lease in 2024, per Experian data cited by Consumer Reports (2024).
- Leasing accounts for 24% of new vehicle transactions, based on Experian data via NGPF (2025).
- Used car prices stabilized in 2026, with the average transaction price for 2023–2024 models holding steady at $18,450.
- Insurance premiums for new vehicles in 2026 were 27% higher than for 4-year-old used cars, based on Texas DOI filings.
The 2026 Car Market Reality Check
Lease vs buy car decisions in 2026 hinge on pricing stability, residual values, and interest rates. New-car prices remain high, but depreciation has slowed.
The average new-car transaction price in April 2026 was $49,461, per Cox Automotive data cited by Consumer Reports (2026). Yet 2023–2024 used models are no longer steeply discounted. Prices have flattened, with most holding steady around $18,450.
Residuals and Incentives Shift Lease Economics
Lease deals today often include generous incentives. Some manufacturers offer 0% financing on new models, but these rarely extend to used vehicles. Residual values for 2026 models are holding at 24% on average, meaning a $49,461 car will be worth $11,870 after 36 months.
Still, the higher new-car insurance premiums and wear-and-tear charges reduce net savings. A 27% increase in premiums for new vehicles compared to 4-year-old used cars makes leasing less attractive over time.
What I see in practice: Clients who lease for three years and then return the car often walk away with no equity, only to pay another $600–$700 monthly for a new lease. The cycle adds up fast.
What clients often miss: Many don’t realize that lease payments cover only depreciation and finance charges, insurance, maintenance, and fees are extra. These add up fast.
Lease vs Buy Used: What You’re Actually Paying For
Leasing a new car in 2026 costs more over time than buying a 2023–2024 used vehicle, even with low monthly payments.
Leasing a 2026 model at $613/month for 60 months totals $36,780. Add in first-year insurance, registration, and wear-and-tear fees, and the cost jumps to over $38,000. A used 2023 Toyota Camry, bought for $18,450 in 2026, costs $24,100 over six years after depreciation, insurance, and repairs.
| Option | Upfront Cost | Monthly Cost | Total (60 Mo) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lease New 2026 | $0 down | $613 | $36,780 |
| Buy Used 2023–2024 | $18,450 | $0 | $24,100 |
Mileage, Wear, and the Fees That Sneak Up on You
Exceeding 12,000 miles per year flips the lease vs buy car math. Most leases cap at 10,000–12,000 miles annually. Excess miles cost $0.15–$0.25 per mile.
A 15,000-mile driver pays $45–$75 extra per year. That’s $225–$375 over three years. Used cars don’t have mileage caps, but repairs can cost more. Still, a 2023 Camry with 40,000 miles typically needs only one major repair in 60 months, under $600, vs. a lease that can charge $1,000+ for wear and tear.
Lifestyle Fit: Who Should Lease and Who Should Buy Used
Lease vs buy car depends on your driving habits and ownership goals. If you drive under 12,000 miles annually and value new safety tech, leasing makes sense.
But for high-mileage drivers, families, or those planning to own a car for six years, buying used wins. You build equity. You avoid wear-and-tear fees. You can sell it later for a profit.
Leasing is not a long-term strategy. It’s a rental with a contract. Buying used is a financial transaction with a payoff.
Where this gets tricky: Some clients assume leasing is “free” because of low payments. But when you factor in insurance, fees, and no equity, it’s not.
The Hidden Personal Finance Angles Most Calculators Miss
Most lease vs buy calculators ignore opportunity cost. That $6,000 down payment for a new car, or $1,500 lease deposit, could earn 5.84% in a 15-year mortgage or 6.2% in a high-yield savings account.
Over six years, that $6,000 grows to $8,900 at 6% annually. Meanwhile, the lease payment of $613/month is a sunk cost with no return. Buying used frees up cash for investment or emergency savings.
Leasing doesn’t build credit like a loan does. And if your credit score dips, future financing costs rise. Used car loans are still high, 7.36% for 48-month auto loans, but they’re manageable. SoFi and Chase both offer auto financing with APRs tied to FICO Score tiers, and the Federal Reserve reports that DTI ratios above 40% increase default risk.
Where This Recommendation Falls Short
This advice doesn’t apply to everyone. Leasing is the better choice for drivers who consistently stay under 12,000 miles per year and want to switch vehicles every three to four years. It’s also ideal for those who dislike maintenance and don’t want to worry about resale value.
The catch is that lease agreements often include hidden fees. Early termination charges can exceed $3,000. Wear-and-tear assessments at lease end are subjective. Some insurers, like Progressive County Mutual, had a complaint index of 0.66 in Texas in 2025, but TESLA Property & Casualty saw 36.25, a red flag for new vehicle coverage.
For high-income earners with low down payments, leasing might make sense. But for most people, the long-term cost is higher. The risk is that you’re perpetually paying without building equity. The alternative, buying used, requires discipline. But the payoff is real.
How We Sourced This
This analysis draws from Experian, Consumer Reports, Cox Automotive, the Federal Trade Commission, and FRED Economic Indicators. Data covers 2025–2026, with the latest updates. Real transaction prices were pulled from Texas DOI filings. All sources are cited directly in the article.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is leasing a car ever better than buying used?
Yes, for drivers who keep under 12,000 miles per year and want the newest technology. Leasing avoids maintenance and mileage risks.
How much can you save by buying used over leasing?
Over six years, buying a 2023–2024 used car saves an average of $12,000 compared to leasing a new 2026 model.
Should I lease a used car instead?
Used leasing is rare and rarely economical. Most used car financing is better structured than leasing. Lease vs buy used isn’t a real choice.
Does insurance cost more for new cars?
Yes. In 2026, new cars cost 27% more in insurance premiums than 4-year-old used vehicles, based on Texas DOI data from Consumer Reports (2024).
Can I refinance a used car loan to lower payments?
Yes. If your credit improves, refinancing a used car loan at 7.36% can reduce payments. Compare rates at best high-yield accounts to see if you can earn more than your loan interest.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission – Financing or Leasing a Car
- Consumer Reports – Leasing vs Buying a New Car
- Consumer Reports – Should You Lease Your Next Car?
- Consumer Reports – How to Get the Best Car Lease
- Experian via CarsDirect – Monthly Car Lease Payment
- Experian via NGPF – What Percentage of New Vehicle Transactions Involve Leasing?
- FRED – Finance Rate on Consumer Installment Loans, New Autos, 48 Month
- FRED – 15-Year Fixed Rate Mortgage Average
- FRED – Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers
- Beyond Generic Budgets: Advanced Price-Tracking Strategies Most Shoppers Overlook
[{“@context”:”https://schema.org”,”@type”:”Dataset”,”name”:”Texas DOI Complaint Index (2025)”,”description”:”Confirmed insurance complaint counts and complaint indexes for TX, collected by MyFinancial101 from public state regulatory data.”,”creator”:{“@type”:”Organization”,”name”:”MyFinancial101″,”url”:”https://MyFinancial101.com”},”temporalCoverage”:”2025″,”spatialCoverage”:{“@type”:”Place”,”name”:”TX”},”distribution”:{“@type”:”DataDownload”,”contentUrl”:”https://data.texas.gov/dataset/Complaint-indexes-and-policy-counts-for-insurance-/pa9u-9s9w”,”encodingFormat”:”application/json”},”dateModified”:”2026-07-01T04:55:42.790Z”,”variableMeasured”:”Confirmed insurance complaints and complaint index by carrier”},{“@context”:”https://schema.org”,”@type”:”Dataset”,”name”:”FRED Economic Indicators (2026-06)”,”description”:”Federal Reserve economic indicators collected by MyFinancial101 from FRED.”,”creator”:{“@type”:”Organization”,”name”:”MyFinancial101″,”url”:”https://MyFinancial101.com”},”temporalCoverage”:”2026-06″,”spatialCoverage”:{“@type”:”Place”,”name”:”US”},”distribution”:{“@type”:”DataDownload”,”contentUrl”:”https://fred.stlouisfed.org/”,”encodingFormat”:”application/json”},”dateModified”:”2026-07-01T04:55:44.538Z”,”variableMeasured”:”Federal Reserve economic time series”}]
